In a December 10, 2024 Siena poll, registered New York voters indicated that cost of living, affordable housing, and crime ranked among their top priorities.
During her January 14, 2025 State of the State Address, Gov. Kathy Hochul focused her attention on these voter priorities. The Governor said, “Our future depends on the ability of every family to afford the essentials of life, and our ability to protect the safety and security of our residents… Our state must be livable, and people must be able to afford to live in it.”
In her opening remarks to kick off the 2025 legislative session, Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins (D-Yonkers) claimed to share voters’ concerns about affordability. Leader Stewart-Cousins (dubiously) asserted that “‘We’ve always kept our focus on affordability,’” adding that “‘We know the challenges ahead require maintaining and strengthening our resolve to make New York more affordable.’”
Just days later, however, the Senate reminded New Yorkers where the true priorities of some of its members lie. On January 21, 2025, the State Senate passed five pro-abortion bills. The following day, in a press release clearly timed to coincide with the 52nd anniversary of the diabolical Roe v. Wade decision that the Supreme Court consigned to the dustbin of history back in 2022, various members of the Senate Majority congratulated themselves and each other for championing these five abortion bills as well as other measures relating to women.
New York legalized elective abortion in 1970. In New York, minors are allowed to obtain abortions without parental notification—let alone parental consent. New Yorkers’ tax dollars pay for the abortions of low-income women through Medicaid. In 2019, New York passed the Reproductive Health Act (RHA), expanding access to late-term abortion and codifying provisions allowing non-physicians to perform abortions. Since Roe was overturned in 2022, New York has passed an array of new laws designed to promote abortion access for New Yorkers and out-of-staters. Last year, New York voters approved the pro-abortion Equal Rights Amendment. Given all this, even pro-choice New Yorkers might deem it strange and unnecessary for the State Senate to spend so much time passing abortion bills in January 2025.
The following abortion-related bills passed on January 21:
- The New York State Abortion Clinical Training Program Act (Bill S.1438-Krueger), which would empower the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH) to train the next generation of abortionists. This bill is, by far, the most destructive of the five abortion-related bills passed by the State Senate on January 21. This bill would provide for the creation of four different abortion training facilities. Physicians, medical residents, nurse practitioners, physicians’ assistants, and midwives would all be eligible for such training. The “policy and purpose” section of the bill asserts that the available supply of abortionists in New York cannot keep up with the growing demand for abortions; clearly, the sponsor of the legislation believes that this a problem. This damaging bill could, by itself, drive up the abortion rate in New York for decades to come. The Senate vote on this bill was 40-19; Sen. Felder was the only Democrat to vote against it, and Republican Sens. Stephen Chan (R-Brooklyn), Jack Martins (R-Great Neck), and Robert Rolison (R-Poughkeepsie) were the only Senate Republicans to support it. (New York Families Action’s memo of opposition to this legislation is available here.)
- Bill S.135-Cleare/A.2137-Gonzalez-Rojas, which would make grant funding available for abortion-related expenses. This bill would expand a reproductive health and equity grant fund that was created in last year’s New York State budget. Under this bill, grant funding from the state could be paid to nonprofit groups that offer low-income women “practical support” (such as meals, transportation, lodging, etc.) when they travel to obtain abortions. Such funding could be paid to out-of-state women who come to New York to obtain abortions. The Senate vote was 39-20. Sen. Felder was the only Democrat to vote against it, and Republican Sens. Chan and Martins were the only Republicans to support it. (New York Families Action’s memo of opposition to this legislation is available here.)
- Bill S.36-A-Mayer/A.2145-A-Reyes, which would allow doctors who prescribe abortion pills to name their respective offices as the prescribers instead of using their own individual names. The purpose is to further promote the availability of abortion pills via telehealth for pregnant women in pro-life states by allowing New York physicians who prescribe such drugs to keep their identities private. The vote was 39-20. Sen. Felder was the only Democrat to vote against it, and Sens. Chan and Martins were the only Republicans to vote for it. Sadly, this bill also passed the New York State Assembly on January 22.
- Bill S.1683-Parker, the Public University Emergency Contraception Education Act, which would provide for the creation of a statewide outreach program of misinformation about so-called “emergency contraception.” This misinformation would include the assertion that “emergency contraception” is “safe,” and would falsely claim that it does not cause abortion. Public university campuses would be required to display and disseminate this misinformation. The vote was 43-16. Sen. Felder was the only Democrat to vote against the bill, while Republican Sens. Patricia Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick (R-Malverne), Chan, Martins, Anthony Palumbo (R-New Suffolk), Rolison, and Bill Weber (R-Montebello) voted for it.
- Bill S.1703-Webb/A.2514-McDonald, which would allow pharmacists to administer injectable contraceptives. While Depo-Provera, an injectable contraceptive, is intended to prevent ovulation, it can sometimes act as an abortifacient by preventing the implantation of a fertilized egg. The state should not expand the availability of
these drugs. The Senate vote was 48-11.
While Bill S.36-A-Mayer/A.2145-A-Reyes has already passed the Assembly, it is hoped that the Assembly will rightfully ignore the other four anti-life pieces of legislation passed by the Senate.
Is the Senate Democratic Conference obsessed with abortion? It certainly seems that way. This apparent obsession is lamentable. To add insult to injury, the Senate Republicans were unable to muster unanimous opposition to even one of these five bills. In fact, Republican Sens. Stephen Chan and Jack Martins voted in favor of all five. New York Families thanks Sen. Felder for swimming against the tide and voting for life, and we also thank the majority of Senate Republicans who did the same.
The next time Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins claims that she and her conference have “‘always kept [their] focus on affordability,’” the appropriate response would be to say, “Are you sure, Senator? You could have fooled us.”
Photo by NY Senate Photo, title: (01-21-25) NY Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins, via Flickr, licensed under CC 2.0