1 Peter 2:11: “Beloved, I urge you as sojourners and exiles to abstain from the passions of the flesh, which wage war against your soul.”
CAUTION: MATURE CONTENT
Should the state of New York pass laws that restrict kids’ access to products that can be harmful and addictive?
Based on existing law, it would seem that the question has already been answered. The Empire State has made it illegal to sell alcohol, tobacco, or marijuana to minors; in fact, it is even illegal to sell these substances to adults under the age of 21. The reasoning behind these laws is clear. Alcohol, tobacco, and marijuana can be addictive and can cause harm to those who use them, particularly if they are used in large quantities. Young people are more likely than older people to take risks without considering the consequences of their conduct, are often influenced by peer pressure, and do not always possess the life experience or the self-control to make wise choices. Therefore, a responsible society should protect young people’s health and safety by restricting their access to alcohol, tobacco, and marijuana.
A bill introduced last week in both houses of the New York State Legislature would protect minors by restricting their access to a different addictive, harmful product: Internet pornography.
Pornography is widely available online and is used by many, many Americans—including Christian Americans. In “Pornography Use Among Young Adults in the United States,” authors Samantha Smith and Jamie LeSueur cite a study showing that in a given year, 69% of men and 40% of women viewed internet pornography. According to Movieguide.org, “a 2022 study found that 73% of teens ages 10 to 17 consumed online pornography—a number that has nearly doubled since 2014.” Troublingly, Movieguide.org also states that 30% of teens have seen pornographic content at school. Barna.com indicates that “just over half of practicing Christians report consuming porn with some level of frequency, including 22 percent who view it weekly (15%) or daily (7%).”
For many pornography users, pornography is addictive. According to Luke Wilkerson of Covenant Eyes, “cravings experienced by someone hooked on porn can be like the cravings of a drug addict.” Wilkerson adds that pornography use gives men a surge of dopamine, a powerful neurotransmitter that makes porn users desire to experience the “high” of pornography repeatedly. With repeated porn use, users’ brains become fatigued and cease to generate as much dopamine, causing users to seek more and more intense pornographic stimulation.
Pornography can lead to a host of harmful consequences. Smith and LeSueur note several harms that result from pornography use; those harms include anxiety, depression, loneliness, lower levels of relationship satisfaction, increased likelihood of connecting sex with violence, anxiety regarding sexual prowess, unhappiness with one’s own appearance and physique, and a higher likelihood of divorce. Smith and LeSueur also assert that teens are especially vulnerable to developing porn addictions because they tend to have less well-developed coping skills than older persons. Wilkerson mentions other problems arising from pornography use, including “fatigue, lack of motivation, inability to concentrate, and escalating tastes for more bizarre or novel porn.” Focus on the Family adds that teen pornography use can lead to an obsession with sex, sexually aggressive behavior, promiscuity, and negative effects on brain development. Furthermore, Movieguide.org states that half of teenagers that use pornography report feeling shame and guilt over their pornography usage.
Obviously, the Bible does not specifically address internet pornography; however, it most certainly does address lust and sexual immorality. The message of our loving God is clear: Lust and sexual immorality are destructive and sinful, and should be avoided. I Corinthians 6:18-20 says, “Flee from sexual immorality. Every other sin a person commits is outside the body, but the sexually immoral person sins against his own body. Or do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit within you, whom you have from God? You are not your own, for you were bought with a price. So glorify God in your body.” Genesis 39 tells the story of Joseph, who set a godly example for others by fleeing from Potiphar’s wife to escape her adulterous advances. In Matthew 5:28, Jesus underscores the seriousness of lust and sexual sin when He says, “‘Everyone who looks at a woman with lustful intent has already committed adultery with her in his heart.’” Indulging in pornography violates the Bible’s teachings on lust and sexual purity.
Given the addictive and harmful nature of pornography, and given the government’s responsibility to protect children and young people, members of the New York State Legislature should offer their strong support to Bill S.3591-Ashby/A.3946-Walsh. This legislation would require commercial entities that publish pornographic content on internet websites to make reasonable efforts to ensure that anyone located in the state of New York while viewing that content is over the age of 18. If passed, Bill S.3591-Ashby/A.3946-Walsh would allow the New York State Attorney General to impose civil penalties of up to $50,000 per day against violators. The legislation is sponsored by Sen. Jake Ashby (R-Castleton) and Asm. Mary Beth Walsh (R-Burnt Hills). New York Families Foundation thanks Sen. Ashby and Asm. Walsh for their leadership on this important issue.
Some may attempt to argue against Bill S.3591-Ashby/A.3946-Walsh on the grounds that it infringes upon the right to free expression under the First Amendment. Such arguments would be futile. In Miller v. California, 413 U.S. 15 (1973), the Supreme Court of the United States held that obscenity falls outside the protections of the First Amendment and may be outlawed. In fact, Sen. Ashby has already addressed this argument, saying, “‘I am not a scholar of constitutional law, but I don’t think James Madison was hoping that children could have unfettered access to hardcore pornography when he crafted the First Amendment.”’
As of March 2024, nineteen other states have passed age verification laws. This year, it is hoped that New York will become the 20th. New York Families calls upon Democrats and Republicans in the New York State Legislature to come together and pass Bill S.3591-Ashby/A.3946-Walsh this year. While the two parties disagree about many things, the need to protect impressionable children from the harm caused by internet pornography should not be one of them.
Photo Credit: DANIEL CONSTANTE / Shutterstock.com