In recent years, many Americans have grown weary of having the “transgender” ideology pushed on them, and many parents have become outraged at seeing activists push that ideology on their children. When it comes to males competing in women’s sports, 79% of Americans—including 67% of Democratic and Democrat-leaning Americans—express opposition. However, a recent U.S. Senate vote demonstrates that dozens of liberal politicians still haven’t gotten the memo.
On March 3, 2025, 45 U.S. Senate Democrats voted to prevent S.9, the Protection of Women and Girls in Sports Act of 2025,[1] from advancing. S.9 would change federal education law in two ways. First, the bill would state that “sex shall be recognized based solely on a person’s reproductive biology and genetics at birth.” Second, S.9 would make it unlawful for a school or other entity that receives federal funds to allow a male to play on a women’s or girls’ sports team.
If passed, S.9 would rectify an injustice. Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 banned sex discrimination in publicly funded education programs across the United States, leading to a surge of sports participation by female American students. Unfortunately, in the 21st century, the transgender movement has worked to institutionalize the lie that a person’s sex is a matter of his or her subjective feelings—not a God-given biological reality. Many public schools and state governments have bent over backwards to accommodate transgenderism, and the results have made a mockery of the intent of Title IX. Allowing males that believe themselves to be “transgender” to compete on women’s and girls’ sports teams discriminates against women and girls, and permitting males that believe themselves to be “transgender” to invade female-only spaces like locker rooms and shower rooms is disrespectful, indecent, and potentially dangerous.
On March 3, the Senate held a cloture vote on S.9. (A cloture vote is an effort to break a filibuster and send a bill to a final vote in the Senate. A three-fifths majority—generally 60 votes—is needed for a cloture vote to succeed.) The cloture vote was rejected; only 51 senators voted in support of the bill, leaving it nine votes short of advancing. Every Republican senator who voted on the bill supported it, while every Democratic senator who voted on the bill—including Sens. Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand of New York—opposed it.
S.9 is a common-sense attempt to safeguard the integrity of women’s and girls’ sports, and it is unfortunate that 45 United States senators are either too brainwashed or too cowardly to support it. Christians in New York and across the country should take notice, and should continue to peacefully and compassionately advocate for gender sanity.[2]
[1] The U.S. House of Representatives passed a similar bill, H.R.28, by a 218-206 vote earlier this year. H.R.28 received bipartisan support, with two House Democrats voting “aye” along with 216 Republicans.
[2] Two brave members of the New York State Legislature, Sen. Alexis Weik (R-Sayville) and Asm. Andrew Molitor (R-Westfield), have introduced legislation to protect women’s sports on the state level. Bill S.4496-Weik/A.4687-Molitor would bar male students in public and private schools from competing in girls’ interscholastic and intramural sporting events. New York Families thanks Sen. Weik and Asm. Molitor for their leadership on this issue.