New York’s Tele-Abortionist Protection Act continues to create problems for the state of Texas. Thankfully, Texas—whose pro-life laws ban the abortion pill—is fighting back in court.
Signed into law by Gov. Kathy Hochul as Chapter 138 of the Laws of 2023, the Tele-Abortionist Protection Act is often referred to as an abortion “shield” law. The Tele-Abortionist Protection Act allows New York abortionists who provide their lethal services to patients in pro-life states via telehealth to escape the legal consequences of violating those states’ abortion laws. Specifically, the law allows abortionists to use telehealth to facilitate pill abortions for out-of-staters without fear of extradition, arrest, professional discipline, or malpractice insurance consequences. The law also prohibits New York courts from cooperating with other states that attempt to punish New York abortionists for violating their pro-life laws. At this writing, 18 states have passed abortion “shield” laws.
Last December, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sued Dr. Margaret Carpenter. Dr. Carpenter, founder of the Abortion Coalition for Telemedicine, is a New York abortionist who allegedly violated Texas law by mailing abortion pills to a Texas woman. After Dr. Carpenter—who is not licensed as a physician in Texas—failed to respond to the lawsuit, Attorney General Paxton obtained a court judgment against her in the amount of $100,000. Attorney General Paxton then attempted to file that Texas judgment at the Ulster County Clerk’s Office so that it could be enforced. However, Acting Ulster County Clerk Taylor Bruck has refused to accept the Texas judgment for filing on the basis that the Tele-Abortionist Protection Act bars him from doing so.
On July 28, 2025, Attorney General Paxton filed a lawsuit seeking to compel Acting Ulster County Clerk Bruck to file the Texas judgment against Dr. Carpenter. Attorney General Paxton commented, “‘Dr. Carpenter is a radical abortionist who must face justice, not get legal protection from New York liberals intent on ending the lives of as many unborn children as they can. No matter where they reside, pro-abortion extremists who send drugs designed to kill the unborn into Texas will face the full force of our state’s pro-life laws.’”
The Hill reported that Gov. Hochul and New York State Attorney General Letitia James “have stood firm on their position to protect Carpenter from extradition or other legal ramifications for providing abortion medication to a patient located outside the state.” Gov. Hochul, who rarely wastes an opportunity to showcase her disdain and disrespect for pro-life people, has asserted that Attorney General Paxton is “‘determined to punish a New York doctor for providing safe, legal abortion care.’” The Governor added, “‘It’s pathetic. It’s dangerous. And it won’t happen on our watch.’”
It is strange that Gov. Hochul should display such unconcern about the impact that New York’s laws have upon other states. In the wake of the horrific mass shooting that occurred in midtown Manhattan on July 28, Gov. Hochul was quick to argue that another state’s gun laws (which the Governor described as “weak”) allowed the shooter to obtain the M4 rifle he used in the attack. If the Governor wants other states to care about the alleged impact that their laws have upon New Yorkers’ lives, she ought to care about the impact of New York’s laws upon the lives of out-of-staters. Along those lines, she should reconsider the Tele-Abortionist Protection Act, which purposefully allows New York tele-abortionists to escape the legal consequences of helping to end the lives of preborn infants in pro-life states.
According to the Albany Times Union, some observers believe that Attorney General Paxton will eventually challenge the validity of New York’s Tele-Abortionist Protection Act in federal court. Such a lawsuit would be welcome. The Full Faith and Credit Clause found in Article IV, Section 1 of the United States Constitution provides that “Full Faith and Credit shall be given in each State to the public Acts, Records, and judicial Proceedings of every other State.” If the federal courts found the Tele-Abortionist Protection Act unconstitutional under the Full Faith and Credit Clause, pro-life states like Texas would be empowered to defend their citizens from tele-abortionists in pro-abortion states like New York. Furthermore, Gov. Hochul and Attorney General James’s scheme of shielding tele-abortionists from the consequences of breaking the pro-life laws of other states will be thwarted.
Photo Credit: Shutterstock.com/1788689192 (Summit Art Creations)