Record Spending, Falling Scores: Tuesday’s School Vote Matters

Tomorrow, May 19, voters across New York State—except those in the “Big Five” city school districts of New York City, Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, and Yonkers, which do not submit their budgets for voter approval—will head to the polls to vote on school budgets and elect school board members.

These elections rarely receive the attention they merit, yet they directly shape our communities’ educational standards, fiscal priorities, and cultural direction. Parents, taxpayers, and Christian voters should not sit this one out.

This year’s elections come amid uncertainty stemming from Albany’s failure to pass a state budget on time. On May 18, the Legislature approved its thirteenth budget extender, temporarily funding government operations more than six weeks after the April 1 deadline. Local school districts were forced to finalize their budgets without knowing exactly how much state aid they would receive. Assembly Minority Leader Ed Ra (R-Garden City) criticized the dysfunction, saying, “The people of this state deserve more than chaos and delays; they deserve a government that plans responsibly and delivers.”

Districts across New York are warning about rising healthcare costs, inflation, transportation expenses, and staffing shortages. School leaders in the Finger Lakes region specifically pointed to health insurance and workforce pressures consuming even modest increases in state aid before those dollars ever reach classrooms.

Still, one thing remains certain: Albany never gives schools less. State education spending continues to rise year after year, even amid fiscal uncertainty. According to new Empire Center data, New York school districts plan to spend an average of more than $37,000 per student next year, with dozens exceeding $50,000 per student. Even the lowest-spending districts plan to spend more than $22,000 per student—well above the national average.

Voters should ask a serious question: What are taxpayers getting for record levels of education spending? New national data released this month by Stanford University’s Educational Opportunity Project and highlighted by The New York Times show that reading scores have declined in 83% of American school districts over the past decade, with many students still performing below grade level despite unprecedented increases in education funding. Researchers described the nation as being in a “reading recession,” warning that academic decline began long before COVID-19 disruptions. Increasingly, parents and education reformers are raising alarms that many children simply are not learning to read proficiently. Critics have pointed to failed “whole language” instructional approaches that deemphasized phonics and sound-based reading instruction in favor of guessing words from context. Multiple states, including the Empire State, are now reversing course and adopting “science of reading” reforms grounded in systematic phonics instruction. The crisis serves as a reminder that higher spending alone does not guarantee better educational outcomes.

Education policy and curriculum decisions matter enormously. School boards increasingly influence curriculum content, library policies, parental rights, discipline standards, school safety, and the broader values reflected in public education. Yet these races often hinge on very low turnout, meaning a handful of engaged citizens can significantly shape the direction of their local schools.

Voting is not merely a civic exercise; it is stewardship.

If you care about fiscal responsibility, academic quality, parental involvement, and the future direction of your local schools, take the time to vote on Tuesday, May 19. When good people stay home, others make the decisions for them.

Image Credit: Lightstock.com/81318

Facebook
LinkedIn
X
Print
Email

This is a pop up

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.